Showing posts with label Arakida Moritake. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arakida Moritake. Show all posts

Friday, February 7, 2014

Poetic Musings: Fallen Flower Haiku by Masaoka Shiki

On the first anniversary of the death of Shimizu

rakka e ni kaeredo hito no yukue kana

a fallen flower returns - yet a man's destination …


This haiku is a play on the celebrated Arakida Moritake haiku (an important influence for Ezra Pound), which itself refers to a scene in a Zeami Noh drama (a significant fact missed by Pound and Blyth, discussed by Hasegawa in his book, haiku no uchu, and others). The Moritake haiku is:

rakka eda ni kaeru to mireba chocho kana

A fallen leaf
Flew back to its branch!
No, it was a butterfly.
(Blyth translation)

Shiki, in his play on Moritake viz Zeami asks, whither the soul of his dearly loved friend? Having exited this world, is a human death but a single "fallen leaf," and, unlike the butterfly, without return? Shiki desperately grieves for his friend and has sworn to devote his life to Shimizu's remembrance...

(As an aside, Blyth quotes the Moritake haiku as an illustrative example of poor poetry, criticizing an "over-reaching" of intellect at the expense of "imagination." He writes (to paraphrase) that haiku should deal with facts, not fantasy or illusion.)

-- excerpted from Richard Gilbert, "A Brilliant Literature: Robert Wilson Interviews Professor Richard Gilbert, Part I," Simply Haiku, 6:4, Winter 2008

(As an aside, Blyth quotes the Moritake haiku as an illustrative example of poor poetry, criticizing an "over-reaching" of intellect at the expense of "imagination." He writes (to paraphrase) that haiku should deal with facts, not fantasy or illusion.)

This reveals that Blyth had no knowledge of one of Japanese poetic devices employed in Moritake's abovementioned haiku:

Read in the context of Japanese classic haiku, technically speaking, there is nothing new about Moritake’ s haiku. In it, he employed a centuries-old poetic device, “mitate” (taking one thing for another) 2 as shown in the following waka:

In my garden
plum blossoms fall –
or is it not rain
but snow, cast down
from the sky?

Otomo No Tabito (665 – 731)

(Addiss, p. 17)

However, this haiku gains more resonance if the reader is aware of the following Zen saying: “The fallen blossom cannot return to its branch.” It makes this saying anew in light of the transformative power of a butterfly. That’s one of the reasons that Moritake’ s haiku is considered “one of the most famous verses of all early haikai poets.” (Addiss, p. 62)

-- excerpted from To the Lighthouse: Haiku as a Form of Super-Position


Reference:

Addiss, Stephen, The Art of Haiku:Its History through Poems and Paintings by Japanese Masters, Shambhala, 2012.